Advertising Information

Change, or Reinforce?


Do you know about the distinction - and it's a useful one - between communication that tries to reinforce and communication that tries to get change?

If you follow politics you'll already be familiar with this idea: Incumbents send messages that reinforce existing voter behavior, while challengers call for changes.

Any thoughtful marketing communication (and political communication is marketing communication) will be strongly influenced by this distinction, which affects not only the content, but also the presentation, and perhaps even the medium.

For example, suppose you own a bookstore and every couple of months you send a newsletter to all residences within a two mile radius.

Now, if you have good market share and you're profitable, you won't want to rock the boat. You'll want to reinforce existing behaviors (which include buying at your store).

On the other hand, if you just opened a new bookstore and need to take market share from other bookstores, then you want change existing book buying behavior.

Another example: Suppose your employee safety program has worked well for the past year and you want to maintain the practices that led to this longest-ever period without an accident. Your communication would reinforce. On the other hand, if the safety record was unacceptable, you would try to get change through your communication.

In a change situation, we want to upset the status quo, to challenge existing beliefs and ways of doing things. That means the words and style could be somewhat inflammatory.

We can do this by making bold claims or allegations: Just listen to, or look at, advertising claims like these: "If you shop at Joe's Bookstore, you may be paying too much!" or, "Drive a bit further and save a lot more at Jane's Bookstore!"

Change also might be hurried by painting negative scenarios , as in "Unless we get more efficient, senior management will outsource the whole department."

Tactically, change usually demands more communication, as in more often and more words or pages. As you can imagine, it takes more communication to drive change than to stay on the same course.

There are also tactics we can use to reinforce existing beliefs or actions.

To maintain the status quo we can stress a service record, as in, "Serving you with quality and service for 25 years." or "Your performance has been very good over the past year, Betty. Keep up the good work."

Reinforcement does not automatically rule out change; however, it emphasizes incremental and gradual change rather than major and abrupt change.

You can also appeal to shared values or experiences to reinforce. Nothing commits us to staying the course like emotional cues that link good times to the status quo. For example, consider the power of an advertising slogan that begins, "Remember when...." It connects a powerful, positive emotion with a product or service. By extension, the product or service offers an opportunity to relive that good time.

In summary, make a distinction in your communication between reinforcing and changing. Decide which way you want to go, and then choose the appropriate strategies, tactics, and tools.

Robert F. Abbott writes and publishes Abbott's Communication Letter. Learn how you can use communication to help achieve your goals, by reading articles or subscribing to this ad-supported newsletter. An excellent resource for leaders and managers, at: http://www.communication-newsletter.com


MORE RESOURCES:
Google

Earthtimes (press release)

Google UK not immune to economic downturn
Times Online, UK - Jul 18, 2008
He did not give a comparison between the first and second quarters, but with revenues from UK search advertising improving by 29.8 per cent overall compared ...
Microsoft feeds cash to Online Services Business NetworkWorld.com
Microsoft?s search ambitions are its Vietnam ZDNet
Google, Microsoft augur tougher times ahead Reuters
CNNMoney.com - Washington Post
all 514 news articles


Telegraph.co.uk

Google misses forecast despite 35 percent jump in profit
San Jose Mercury News,  USA - Jul 18, 2008
In another important indicator, meanwhile, Google said paid advertising clicks - the number of times that Internet users clicked on paid advertisements ...
Google shares slide as search engine faces up to slower US slowdown Telegraph.co.uk
Google Cautious On Consumer Spending Patterns CNNMoney.com
Google shares tumble 8% on earnings report San Francisco Chronicle
New York Times - InternetNews.com
all 214 news articles


WorldNetDaily

Charleston: not as gay as its ads
Independent, UK - 17 hours ago
A gay rights group has stepped into the breach in a spat over an advertising campaign designed to promote South Carolina as a favourite pink-pound ...
S. Carolina Huffs Over UK 'Gay' Ads TIME
No one looks good in ad campaign foul-up Hilton Head Island Packet
so gay' travel agency to get refund guardian.co.uk
Telegraph.co.uk - Newsweek
all 219 news articles


Media General reports 2Q loss on lower advertising
Bizjournals.com, NC - Jul 18, 2008
Classified advertising in the Media General publishing division was down $14.1 million, or 29 percent. In the company's three metro markets -- Winston-Salem ...


Brocktown News

Media General Reports June 2008 Revenues
FOXBusiness - Jul 17, 2008
The 9.8 percent decline was primarily attributable to lower Publishing Division revenues, driven by continued weakness in Classified advertising in the ...
Media General Swings to Loss, Warns Of Big Goodwill Write-Down Editor & Publisher
Media General 2Q Revs Dismal MediaPost Publications
Media General, Inc. Q2 2008 Earnings Call Transcript Seeking Alpha
Bizjournals.com - Bizjournals.com
all 120 news articles


Internet gets new advertising model
Arizona Republic, AZ - 20 hours ago
by Rachel Dodes - Jul. 19, 2008 12:00 AM In a new effort to attract a younger audience and capture marketing dollars that are increasingly going to the Web, ...
Make It Work: Vogue Launches Reality Show ABC News
all 4 news articles


Advertising loses some of its voice
guardian.co.uk, UK - 11 hours ago
Because after decades of receiving complaints about TV adverts sounding louder than the programmes, the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) has finally ...


ITV.com

Western Olympic Ads Cheerlead for China
New York Times, United States - 4 hours ago
An Adidas campaign showing the Chinese masses supporting top athletes was honored at an international advertising festival. By DAVID BARBOZA BEIJING ? It is ...
Coke paints China red for Olympic Games Atlanta Journal Constitution
all 793 news articles


Direct Traffic Media

Google Search Ads Stronger
InternetNews.com - 15 hours ago
JP Morgan's Imran Khan agreed, writing in a research note that "search advertising will continue to perform well in a weak economy. ...
Google Buys Online Ad Business in Russia New York Times
Google marches into Russia with ad buy VNUNet.com
Rambler Media has announced that they are now selling their Begun ... TechWhack (press release)
CNET News - eWeek
all 81 news articles


Bundesliga chairman warns league is headed toward financial trouble
The Canadian Press, BERLIN - 8 hours ago
Seifert also warned against other pieces of legislation that could drain the league's income, including a proposed ban on alcohol advertising in stadiums. ...

Advertising - Google News

home | site map
© 2007